Car Subscription vs. Leasing: Which Model Fits Your Situation?

The decision between an Car Subscription and a traditional leasing contract depends on how you intend to use the vehicle. Both models allow you to drive a car without owning it, but they differ significantly regarding costs, contract duration, and administrative effort.

This guide compares the two options based on practical factors, including monthly expenses, contract obligations, and risk.

‍

Car Subscription vs. Leasing: The Differences

Car Subscription

A car subscription is an all-inclusive method of accessing a vehicle. You pay a single monthly price that typically covers insurance, maintenance, servicing, taxes, and registration.

The terms are fixed, usually for 12 or 24 months. The contract ends automatically when the term expires. Providers like Carrivo utilise a digital approval (Prüfung) process and standardized documentation for vehicle pickup and return.

Leasing

Leasing is the traditional model in Germany for accessing a vehicle over a longer period. Contracts usually last between 36 and 48 months and cover the cost of the vehicle itself. You must organize insurance, maintenance, and taxes separately. This model offers control but requires you to manage these responsibilities personally. Leasing is suitable if you need long-term stability and do not expect changes in your mobility needs.

‍

Cost Comparison: What You Actually Pay

Comparing the monthly rates of a car subscription and leasing can be misleading. A leasing rate often appears lower because it excludes operational costs that must be calculated separately.

Monthly Payments

• Car Subscription: The monthly fee covers running costs. It includes insurance, maintenance, inspections, vehicle taxes, and registration. This results in a fixed, predictable monthly expense.
• Leasing: The advertised rate covers the usage of the car. You pay separately for insurance, maintenance, and taxes. These additional costs vary based on the vehicle type and your insurance history.

Upfront Costs

• Car Subscription: High deposits are uncommon. Instead, there is usually a one-time "Start- bzw. Bereitstellungsgebühr" (start or setup fee). This covers the logistics of registration, preparation, and vehicle handover.
• Leasing: A down payment (Sonderzahlung) is common. This payment makes the monthly leasing rate appear lower but it does not reduce the total cost of the car; it simply shifts a portion of the payment to the start of the contract. Start-up or service fees may also apply.

To compare costs accurately over 24 months, you must add the leasing down payment, monthly rates, and two years of insurance and maintenance, then compare that total to the car subscription all-inclusive price.

Insurance

Insurance costs in leasing depend on your personal "Schadenfreiheitsklasse" (no-claims bonus). If you have no insurance history, premiums can be high. Furthermore, if you cause an accident in a leased car, your personal insurance premium will likely increase the following year.

In a car subscription, insurance is included. Accidents typically do not affect your personal insurance history.

‍

Flexibility and Contract Terms

Your mobility needs may change over time. The primary difference here is the commitment length.

Car Subscription

You select a fixed term (e.g., 12 or 24 months). When the term ends, the contract ends. You cannot swap cars during the contract, but the shorter duration allows you to change models more frequently than leasing. If your needs change, you are not bound to the vehicle for several years.

Leasing

Leasing contracts typically run for three to five years. Terminating these contracts early is difficult and often involves significant penalty fees. This makes leasing a stable option, but it lacks flexibility if your personal situation changes.

‍

Summary: Which Option is Right for You?

Car Subscription is suitable for:

• Drivers who require flexibility and shorter commitments.
• Users who prefer a single, all-inclusive price.
• New drivers or those without a German insurance history.

Leasing is suitable for:

• Drivers with stable, long-term plans (3+ years).
• Drivers with a strong insurance history (low premiums).
• Companies or individuals who prefer to manage their own fleet administration.

‍

Conclusion

Car Subscription and leasing serve different needs. A subscription offers shorter terms and bundled services, providing a simple way to stay mobile. Leasing is effective for those who don't mind long-term commitments and managing their own vehicle services.

Carrivo focuses on the subscription model with fixed terms and automatic contract termination.

To understand the specific costs of a subscription, view the pricing overview.